Kalshi faces a renewed attempt by New York authorities to restrict its prediction market after two federal court setbacks this week. The exchange and its federal regulator argue that an order against operations in New York could affect customers nationwide.
On Friday, November 20, U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield rejected an emergency request from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to stop New York Attorney General Letitia James from pursuing enforcement against Kalshi. Schofield said the regulator had “not established a likelihood of success on the merits” of its claim that federal law prevents states from enforcing gambling rules against prediction markets.
The decision followed a separate ruling on Thursday. U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick ordered New York’s lawsuit returned to state court, finding that the federal court lacked authority to hear the case. Broderick did not decide whether Kalshi's contracts violate state gambling laws. His order addressed which court should handle the dispute, rather than its outcome.
Following the transfer, New York officials renewed their request for a temporary restraining order. Kalshi asked the state court for an opportunity to respond before any emergency restriction takes effect. The proposed order remains a request, not a confirmed shutdown of the exchange.
The CFTC argues that Kalshi operates under federal rules for derivatives exchanges rather than individual state gambling licenses. In its Friday filing, the agency warned that an order preventing Kalshi from offering contracts “within or from” New York could force it to “cease all operations” because its headquarters and exchange operations are based there.
The regulator had already issued an emergency directive in August, instructing Kalshi to continue operating under federal market rules. At the time, the CFTC said New York wanted to prohibit all of the company's event contracts nationwide and sought more than $36 billion in damages.
Kalshi has challenged the state's position. Spokeswoman Elisabeth Diana said the exchange has complied with the law since receiving federal authorization. She added that the company wants to reach a resolution with New York officials that protects its 1.2 million users in the state.
New York sued Kalshi on July 31, accusing it of offering gambling without a license from the New York State Gaming Commission. James argues that contracts tied to sports, elections and other events fall under state gambling laws. She previously said, “No matter what they call themselves, prediction markets like Kalshi are gambling platforms, plain and simple.”
The state also alleges that Kalshi permits customers aged 18 to 20 to trade sports contracts even though New York requires sports bettors to be at least 21. Kalshi disputes the state's authority over its federally regulated products. In October 2025, the state's Gaming Commission ordered Kalshi to stop offering unlicensed sports wagering. A federal judge denied Kalshi's attempt to block that order in July 2026. However, courts around the country have reached different decisions on the wider question.
Three federal appeals courts have allowed state oversight arguments to proceed against Kalshi, while another reached a different conclusion in a New Jersey dispute. That split leaves the wider question of federal and state authority unresolved. The CFTC has pursued similar disputes elsewhere, including a lawsuit against Arkansas announced on November 13. Meanwhile, New York's request for a restraining order remains before the state court this week.
Also Read: Crypto Market Today: Ethereum, Zcash, Altcoins Face Selling Amid Bitcoin ETF Outflows