

Ford, Honda, Stellantis' FCA unit and Volkswagen sued New Jersey on Friday to block a law governing dealer payments for warranty and recall work. In a federal complaint filed in Trenton, the automakers argued that the statute lets franchised dealers charge inflated amounts for labor and parts.
They estimate that the rules will transfer more than USD 375 million a year from manufacturers to dealerships. A New Jersey dealers' group disputes their claims and says the law addresses longstanding gaps in repair payments.
The New Jersey Motor Vehicle Open Recall Notice and Fair Compensation Act took effect on April 1. Former Governor Phil Murphy signed the measure in September 2025, changing how manufacturers reimburse dealers for certain repairs. The FCA unit represents brands including Fiat and Chrysler in the challenge.
The companies objected to a provision that lets dealers calculate a labor multiplier using samples of repair orders. They argue that the method can produce bills for more hours than technicians actually spend working.
Their complaint also challenges rules requiring payments for parts at marked-up rates, even when dealers obtained them cheaply or without charge. The automakers say the statute prevents them from supplying lower-priced parts when market conditions support price reductions.
Since April, each manufacturer has received dozens of bills it considers excessive, according to the lawsuit. Some allegedly exceed comparable dealers' charges and retail customer rates, while others cover labor time nobody worked.
The manufacturers contend that dealers face no obligation to use the extra money for better customer service or higher employee pay. They describe the expected annual transfer as a windfall for dealerships rather than a direct improvement to repair work. In their complaint, they say the law rewards dealers for charging retail customers more.
Ford, Honda, FCA and Volkswagen allege the statute violates the US Constitution's Commerce Clause and Takings Clause. They also argue that federal recall law overrides parts of the state statute and that it conflicts with New Jersey's Constitution.
The automakers describe the payment structure as a ‘blank check’ for dealers. They say it leaves manufacturers with no practical way to avoid what they call ‘extortionate’ charges or recover the increased costs.
The New Jersey Coalition of Automotive Retailers, a nonprofit advocacy group, is also a defendant. Its president, Laura Perrotta, expressed confidence that the group would prevail in court.
Perrotta accused manufacturers of benefiting for decades from steep discounts on dealership parts and labor. She also said dealers cannot simply pass warranty and recall repair costs to consumers while competing for business.
When lawmakers enacted the measure, the coalition said it would bring manufacturer reimbursements closer to retail repair rates. The group also presented the law as protection for technicians and consumers.
Also Read: Ford Enters Battery Manufacturing with First US-Made LFP Cells
Beyond repair reimbursement, the statute provides payments to dealers holding used cars they cannot sell because recall parts are unavailable. Under certain conditions, compensation starts after 30 days and reaches at least 1.5% of a vehicle's value each month.
New Jersey registration notices must also direct vehicle owners to the federal recall database. The notices must explain that eligible recall work generally comes without charge at authorized dealerships.
The measure generally gives manufacturers 30 days to approve or reject reimbursement requests. If they reject a claim, they must explain the decision in writing. It also prevents manufacturers from penalizing dealers for submitting eligible claims.
How much control should manufacturers have over dealership repair charges under the new rules? The lawsuit disputes the method for calculating reimbursements, while the statute sets procedures for reviewing contested bills.
The office of New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport, which enforces state laws, declined to comment on the case.