Ethereum Brothers Acquitted in USD 25M Wire Fraud Case

A federal judge has cleared Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of criminal charges over a USD 25 million Ethereum trading operation. Prosecutors failed to establish material misrepresentation. The decision follows a November 2025 mistrial.
US judge acquits MIT brothers in $25 million Ethereum fraud case, citing lack of deception
Written By:
Yusuf Islam
Published on: 
Updated on: 

A U.S. federal judge has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of criminal charges related to a USD 25 million Ethereum trading operation. Federal prosecutors alleged that the brothers executed the operation in just 12 seconds. In a 46-page opinion dated November 16, District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke found that the government failed to establish material misrepresentation, a necessary element of wire fraud.

Ethereum Brothers

The decision clears the Massachusetts Institute of Technology-educated brothers of wire fraud and two conspiracy charges involving wire fraud and money laundering. Their previous trial ended in a mistrial in November 2025 after jurors failed to reach a unanimous verdict.

Ethereum Trading Rules Undermine Federal Fraud Case

Clarke examined whether Ethereum participants make binding promises when submitting transactions or registering validators. The court also reviewed the obligations associated with software that organizes blockchain transactions.

“It is a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use,” Clarke wrote, referring to Ethereum. Prosecutors argued that the brothers deceived automated traders by submitting transactions intended to attract their trading bots. They subsequently disrupted the sequence of trades that those programs had arranged.

But did submitting transactions to Ethereum's public pool create an obligation to execute them in a particular order?

Clarke found no such agreement. She also rejected the government's comparison between the brothers' activities and spoofing in conventional financial markets. The brothers never canceled their bait transactions, and the blockchain recorded them within approximately one minute.

Furthermore, neither Ethereum nor the MEV-Boost software specifications imposed the obligations that formed part of the prosecution's case.

How the Brothers Earned USD 25 Million Through Omakase

Court records show that the brothers spent several months preparing an operation they called Omakase. They registered 16 Ethereum validators and targeted automated programs that engaged in sandwich trading.

Sandwich trading involves purchasing tokens before another user's pending buy order and selling them afterward. Traders use this technique to profit from price changes that the intervening purchase creates.

In April 2023, eight transactions from the brothers attracted sandwich trading bots. These programs arranged transactions to generate profits from the anticipated purchases. The brothers then exploited a vulnerability in relay software associated with MEV-Boost. Flashbots introduced the open-source software in 2022.

The vulnerability gave the brothers access to transaction information that validators would not ordinarily receive before committing to publish a proposed block.

With this information, they rearranged the transactions and disrupted the automated traders' intended sales. The operation generated approximately USD 25 million in profits.

Three sandwich traders incurred losses, including Savannah Technologies. Meanwhile, the brothers' validator received a penalty of 1 ETH for proposing two blocks during the same production slot.

Read More: Bitcoin Falls 12.7% in a Week, Ethereum Down 13.2%

Federal Judge Rejects MEV-Boost Fraud Allegations

The government also challenged information within a digitally signed block header that the brothers submitted to the Ultrasound Relay. Clarke acknowledged that the header contained incorrect information.

Yet evidence from the trial showed that the relay did not inspect the disputed fields before releasing transaction data. Clarke wrote that the information “had no impact on the behavior of its recipient.”

Prosecutors presented no expert witness on Ethereum's trading environment. They also did not call an Ultrasound representative, while only one of the three affected sandwich traders testified.

Clarke referenced a separate 2025 ruling involving Mango Markets trader Avraham Eisenberg. That decision found that platform users' expectations did not establish that the defendant had made a false promise.

Federal authorities arrested the brothers in May 2024 following an investigation involving the Internal Revenue Service's Criminal Investigation unit. Each of the three original charges carried a maximum prison sentence of 20 years.

Clarke rejected an earlier motion to dismiss the fraud charges in July 2025. Prosecutors separately abandoned a charge involving conspiracy to receive stolen property.

Court records also show that Flashbots temporarily blacklisted the validator and updated its relay software within 24 hours of the incident. A wallet containing USD 3 million remained subject to a freeze, while the brothers had converted their remaining profits into U.S. dollars by October 2023.

Conclusion

The federal court acquitted the Peraire-Bueno brothers after prosecutors failed to establish material misrepresentation in their USD 25 million Ethereum trading operation. The ruling also cleared the money laundering conspiracy charge because it depended on proceeds from the alleged wire fraud.

Join our WhatsApp Channel to get the latest news, exclusives and videos on WhatsApp