Why Bitcoin Treasury Companies are Facing a New Valuation Challenge in 2026

Bitcoin treasury companies face growing valuation pressure as Strategy, Metaplanet and Strive shares decline, while rising debt, shrinking premiums and MSCI index exclusions threaten investor confidence
Why Bitcoin Treasury Companies are Facing a New Valuation Challenge in 2026
Written By:
Bhavesh Maurya
Reviewed By:
Manisha Sharma
Published on: 
Updated on: 

Bitcoin treasury companies are facing a difficult question: Why should investors pay a premium for corporate shares when they can buy Bitcoin directly? Falling share valuations, borrowing obligations and index exclusions are challenging the strategy of issuing securities to accumulate cryptocurrency.

Valuation Premiums Shrink

The key metric is market-value-to-net-asset-value, or mNAV, comparing a company's market valuation against its underlying Bitcoin exposure. Above 1.0, firms can potentially issue shares at a premium and acquire additional Bitcoin without diluting existing holders' exposure. Below that threshold, raising equity becomes less attractive.

CoinDesk's October institutional adoption report states that Strategy shares fell 14.7% during October, compared with Bitcoin's 7.6% decline. Metaplanet lost 16.6%, Twenty One Capital declined 15.7%, and Strive dropped 24.5%.

These differences show that treasury equities can suffer when Bitcoin prices and investor confidence weaken simultaneously.

Strategy's Balance Sheet Shows the Trade-Off

Strategy's November 15 briefing reported 850,849 BTC, representing approximately 4.05% of Bitcoin's maximum supply. At the report's assumed Bitcoin price of USD 68,800, those holdings were valued at USD 58.54 billion.

But investors must also account for USD 6.71 billion in debt and USD 12.71 billion in preferred securities. Annual interest and dividend obligations totaled approximately USD 1.43 billion.

The briefing calculated an mNAV of 1.09 using net Bitcoin value per share. Alternative trackers applying different definitions can show a discount, showing why valuation comparisons require consistent methods.

Index Exclusions Add Pressure

Reuters reported MSCI’s plans to remove Strategy and other companies classified as investment-like businesses from indexes on December 1. JPMorgan previously estimated Strategy could face up to USD 8.8 billion in outflows if other index providers adopted similar exclusions. That is a conditional scenario, not confirmed selling.

MSCI's review targeted firms whose digital assets account for at least 50% of total assets, questioning whether they resemble operating businesses or investment funds. Exclusion threatens passive investment demand and could make future equity fundraising substantially costlier.

What Investors Should Measure Next

Corporate treasuries nevertheless continued accumulating Bitcoin. October corporate Bitcoin holdings totaled USD 101.5 billion, or 79% of tracked digital-asset treasury assets, despite a 6.47% monthly decline.

CoinDesk reported October additions of 15,976 BTC, worth approximately USD 1.24 billion, across tracked companies. However, rising holdings do not automatically improve shareholder returns. New shares can dilute ownership, while debt and preferred dividends take priority over common equity.

Investors increasingly need to examine Bitcoin per diluted share, cash reserves, financing costs and operating income alongside headline treasury balances.

The decisive test is whether each company creates more attributable Bitcoin value per share after financing costs, rather than merely increasing the number of coins it holds.

Also Read: Strategy and Strive Signal Bitcoin Buying Interest as MARA Sells USD 1.1 Billion


FAQs:

1. Why are Bitcoin treasury companies facing valuation challenges in 2026?

Bitcoin treasury companies are experiencing pressure from falling stock prices, shrinking valuation premiums, rising financing obligations and potential index exclusions. Investors are questioning whether owning these companies offers sufficient advantages over directly purchasing Bitcoin.

2. What is mNAV, and why is it important for Bitcoin treasury companies?

Market-value-to-net-asset-value (mNAV) compares a company's market valuation with the value of its underlying Bitcoin exposure. A premium above 1.0 can support equity fundraising, while a discount may make issuing additional shares less attractive.

3. How much Bitcoin does Strategy hold, and what are its financial obligations?

According to its November 15 briefing, Strategy held 850,849 BTC, valued at approximately USD 58.54 billion using an assumed Bitcoin price of USD 68,800. The company also reported USD 6.71 billion in debt, USD 12.71 billion in preferred securities and approximately USD 1.43 billion in annual interest and dividend obligations.

4. How could MSCI index exclusions affect Bitcoin treasury companies?

MSCI's announced exclusions could reduce passive investment demand for companies classified as investment-like businesses rather than traditional operating companies. JPMorgan estimated that Strategy could face up to USD 8.8 billion in outflows if other index providers adopted similar exclusions, although this remains a conditional scenario.

5. What should investors consider before investing in Bitcoin treasury stocks?

Investors should evaluate Bitcoin holdings per diluted share, mNAV, outstanding debt, preferred dividends, cash reserves and operating income. Increasing Bitcoin reserves does not automatically improve shareholder returns if financing costs, share dilution or declining cryptocurrency prices offset the additional holdings.

Join our WhatsApp Channel to get the latest news, exclusives and videos on WhatsApp

                                                                                                       _____________                                             

Disclaimer: Analytics Insight does not provide financial advice or guidance on cryptocurrencies and stocks. Also note that the cryptocurrencies mentioned/listed on the website could potentially be risky, i.e. designed to induce you to invest financial resources that may be lost forever and not be recoverable once investments are made. This article is provided for informational purposes and does not constitute investment advice. You are responsible for conducting your own research (DYOR) before making any investments. Read more about the financial risks involved here.