News

US Senate Democrats Challenge CFTC Prediction Markets Directive

Senate Democrats have challenged the CFTC’s directive requiring prediction markets to operate nationwide. Lawmakers argue that the order conflicts with existing court rulings. Meanwhile, the regulator continues its legal battle against state-level gambling restrictions.

Written By : Yusuf Islam
Reviewed By : Pranchal Srivastava

US Senate Democrats have called on the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to withdraw its directive against geographic restrictions on prediction markets. In a Monday letter, lawmakers argued that the federal regulator’s instructions conflict with active court orders and undermine state and tribal laws. The dispute concerns platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket as several states seek to enforce gambling restrictions.

Senate Democrats Push Back Against CFTC Directive

Earlier this month, the CFTC instructed regulated prediction markets to remove restrictions that prevent residents of certain states from trading event contracts. The agency gave these platforms 30 days to comply or explain why they could not operate nationwide.

Lawmakers on the Senate Agriculture Committee subsequently challenged that position. Their letter argued that several courts had already ordered prediction market operators to suspend certain services in jurisdictions where local gambling restrictions apply.

The senators, including Adam Schiff of California and Elissa Slotkin of Michigan, cited court orders covering Michigan, Nevada and Washington. They also pointed to restrictions involving the lands of two California tribes.

CFTC Chairman Mike Selig maintains that federal derivatives laws take precedence over state gambling restrictions. Under his interpretation, designated contract markets must operate uniformly across all 50 states.

But can the CFTC enforce nationwide access while court orders continue to restrict prediction markets in certain jurisdictions?

The senators have asked the agency to withdraw its instructions until the courts resolve the outstanding legal disputes. Different rulings from federal courts could eventually bring the matter before the US Supreme Court.

Louisiana and Arkansas Expand Prediction Market Legal Battles

Meanwhile, Louisiana has joined the growing number of jurisdictions pursuing restrictions on prediction markets. A judge recently cleared the way for state authorities to prohibit trading in certain event contracts.

The Louisiana Gaming Control Board had previously classified certain event contracts, including those involving sporting outcomes, as illegal gambling. A temporary restraining order targeted several companies operating in the sector.

These companies include Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase, Gemini and Crypto.com. In response, the CFTC filed a lawsuit seeking to stop Louisiana from enforcing the restrictions.

Crypto.com and other companies have also sought to participate in the federal regulator’s legal action. Selig criticized Louisiana’s lawsuit and argued that the state should allow event contract trading to continue while litigation proceeds.

Alongside the Louisiana dispute, the CFTC has filed a lawsuit against Arkansas to defend its regulatory authority over prediction markets. Arkansas had earlier sued Kalshi on November 4 over allegations that the company operated an illegal gambling business.

Arkansas is also the home state of John Boozman, who chairs the Senate Agriculture Committee. The committee oversees the CFTC and its regulatory activities.

Read More: US Senate Sets September Vote on CLARITY Act After Crypto Bill Delayed

CFTC Leadership Faces Changes Amid Regulatory Disputes

The disagreement comes as Selig remains the only commissioner at the CFTC. Although the agency normally has five commissioners, its leadership has operated with a single member for an extended period.

The White House has nominated Republican Nathan Anonick and Democrat Matthew Rowland to fill two vacancies. Anonick works with the Senate Agriculture Committee, while Rowland previously advised a Democratic CFTC commissioner.

The Senate Agriculture Committee has scheduled a confirmation hearing for both nominees on Tuesday. Their appointments would bring additional members into the agency’s regulatory decision-making process.

Commissioners from opposing political parties can issue dissenting opinions when they disagree with agency decisions. Those opinions can also become relevant during subsequent legal challenges involving regulatory policies.

Commissioners must also refrain from participating in decisions that involve potential conflicts of interest. Selig previously worked as a private-sector lawyer representing cryptocurrency businesses. As the agency’s sole commissioner, his ability to withdraw from matters requiring CFTC action remains constrained.

Meanwhile, Democrats will assume the Senate majority in less than two months, giving the party control over the Agriculture Committee’s agenda and oversight of the federal derivatives regulator.

Conclusion

Senate Democrats want the CFTC to withdraw its nationwide prediction markets directive until courts settle disputes over federal and state regulatory authority. Meanwhile, lawsuits involving Louisiana and Arkansas continue as the Senate prepares to consider two new commissioners for the federal derivatives regulator.

Join our WhatsApp Channel to get the latest news, exclusives and videos on WhatsApp

Canada’s C-22 Sparks Crypto and Privacy Backlash from Vitalik Buterin

Wells Fargo Doubles Bitcoin ETF Holdings to USD 2.35 Billion

Trezor Data Breach Exposes 27,000 Orders as Scam Calls Begin

Crypto News Today: Tether Capital Invests in Nomad, Binance Hacker Moves Funds, PI Hits All-Time Low

Ethereum Price Recovers Above USD 1,800 as Goldman Sachs Expands ETF Holdings Despite Outflows